The state of fixing things

By: aSigiam , 4:02 AM GMT on August 10, 2012

Another interesting article from Design News. As a Do-it-yourself type, it raises some interesting issues. Whether by design or not, cars have been harder to work on year after year.

Do You Have a Right to Repair What You Own?

Jon Titus, Contributing Technical Editor
8/8/2012 29 comments

Companies, engineers, and product designers should keep their eyes on Massachusetts. The Massachusetts Right to Repair Coalition (MRRC), which comprises independent mechanics and parts retailers, has worked on a "right to repair" ballot initiative for the November 2012 election. The coalition contends auto manufacturers will not sell their members the same diagnostic and repair tools sold to the manufacturer's dealers. If passed by voters, the law would compel vehicle manufacturers to make tools and repair information available for anyone to buy. I suppose buyers in the Bay State could resell to anyone they wish, thus making the "close to the vest" tools and information widely available.

Of course, the authorized auto dealers want to protect their profitable repair and service businesses. According to the Wall Street Journal:

Opponents say 'right to repair' could give independent auto parts makers access to carmakers’ proprietary designs, leading to substandard knockoffs. The Alliance of Automobile Manufacturers says 'right to repair' is unnecessary because car companies already provide repair information for a fee to mechanics. Backers of the measure say that information can be spotty and incomplete.

I remember a time when any shade-tree mechanic could go to the local library or auto parts store and buy a Chilton manual for his make and model car. The manual provides detailed repair and maintenance information, and I don't recall any problems with "substandard knockoff" replacement parts. People bought parts from a dealer or they purchased name brand parts from an independent supplier or chain store. Chilton manuals helped me repair brakes, replace a heater, add electrical controls to a car, tune up engines, rebuild carburetors, and so on. I figure if I buy something, I should have the option to repair it on my own.

Some people have complained about Apple's use of a "pentalobe" screw head in new products, perhaps to discourage people from opening their Mac computers, iPhones, and iPads. Of course, you can now buy a pentalobe screwdriver. But I see a big difference between reverse engineering a screwdriver and reverse engineering electronic diagnostic tools for an automobile, or for lab instruments.

The Massachusetts Right to Repair Coalition provided the following information on its Website:

Last week, a customer brought a Mercedes in to East Main Auto in Northborough. It had a problem with its transmission. East Main specializes in Mercedes repair, but owner Kenny Giles was forced to bring the car to a Mercedes dealership to buy the appropriate part. 'Mercedes wouldn’t release the part, because we’re not a Mercedes dealership,' said Giles. It took the mechanic an extra day to fix the car, and probably cost a little bit more money. It happens a lot with new cars. Independent dealerships aren’t given the software, diagnostic tools or parts needed to fix certain cars so owners are forced to return to the dealership for repair.

Have you found yourself in a similar situation? I have. I also have found manufacturers use their own cryptic part numbers, so even if you know a part has died, you cannot figure out what to replace it with. You must buy the component from the manufacturer or an authorized repair center. That's fine for something proprietary, but it stinks if the manufacturer's "QBX-81" transistor is simply a remarked inexpensive 2N3904. If you own something, you should have access to the same documents, tools, and parts as everyone else.

Reader Comments

Comments will take a few seconds to appear.

Post Your Comments

Please sign in to post comments.

Sign In or Register Sign In or Register

Not only will you be able to leave comments on this blog, but you'll also have the ability to upload and share your photos in our Wunder Photos section.

Display: 0, 50, 100, 200 Sort: Newest First - Order Posted

Viewing: 1 - 1

Page: 1 — Blog Index

1. GardenGrrl
3:31 PM GMT on August 10, 2012
Amen, Amen, brother! I think it borders on criminal how manufacturers will make proprietary parts, mark them up 300% and require you to use their mechanics.
I'm a fairly decent mechanic but have for the most part stopped working on my own car since my '84 Honda.

Industrial equipment is the same way. One place had an air-compressor where even the panel screw threads where proprietary...don't strip one of those.

I wholeheartedly agree with that bill. A little competition for car dealerships would lead to better service and perhaps better pricing.
Member Since: March 25, 2007 Posts: 289 Comments: 11462

Viewing: 1 - 1

Page: 1 — Blog Index

Top of Page

Dribbling Bits

About aSigiam

Gardening has been one of my hobbies as well as photography and just being outdoors.

Local Weather

Heavy Rain
40 °F
Heavy Rain

aSigiam's Recent Photos

on a clear night
moon rising
Standing Guard